Kyle Hanslovan, a cyber-warfare specialist serving with the 175th Cyberspace Operations Group of the Maryland Air National Guard, works at Warfield Air National Guard Base, Middle River, Md., Oct. 30, 2017. Although both sides have been targeting each other's infrastructure since at least 2012, according to the Times article, the aggression and scope of these operations now seems unprecedented. The Department of Defense provides the military forces needed to deter war and ensure our nation's security. The New York Cyber Task Forces 2017 report discusses the idea of leverage, for instance, in a somewhat productized sense vis--vis software and internet security. A cyberattack does not necessarily require a cyber response, she added. Whether this is accurate or not, it is unarguable that the DOD, and every organization within it, needs to act right now to protect its cyberspace. These concepts describe the approach required for the cyberspace domain. Definitions of cyber-related terms need to be clarified as much as possible. Accurate reporting of the cybersecurity status of DOD cyberspace is critical. (Figure 4). Stretch Film Division. Sgt. Jan / endangered animals in north america / The Russian author does not speculate on national interests per se but does describe major cyber-related disagreements between Russia and the U.S. in at least three major areas: the role of government in overseeing cyberspace; the militarization of cyberspace and the related applicability of existing international law; and the idea of legally binding treaties versus non-binding guidelines for how information and communication technologies should be used. One example of the Department of Defense's way to leverage the cyberspace enterprise to further the United State's interest in relation to NATO is to collaborate with international partners especially with the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) members. While the authors are all affiliated with different institutions, they have written this paper in their personal capacity, representing the views of neither their organizations nor their governments. November 4, 2022 The Pardee RAND Graduate School (PardeeRAND.edu) is home to the only Ph.D. and M.Phil. feeling rejected by wife during pregnancy . While the United States has displayed a growing willingness to launch operations against Russia, Moscow has somewhat bolstered its military cyber capacity by expanding recruiting initiatives and malware development. If not, what are some next-best alternatives? While the U.S. military built up the latter, the issue of when and where the United States should use cyber operations failed to keep pace with new capabilities. Moscow sees an unwavering cyber omnipotence in the United States, capable of crafting uniquely sophisticated malware like the Stuxnet virus, all while using digital operations to orchestrate regional upheaval, such as the Arab Spring in 2011. by Olivia Angelino, Thomas J. Bollyky, Elle Ruggiero and Isabella Turilli From a defensive cyberspace perspective, the threat to the Department of Defense (DOD) has never been greater. The Russian government tries to maintain greater control over domestic cyberspace than does the U.S., primarily to ensure political stability. Increasing its promotion of science, technology, engineering and math classes in grade schools to help grow cyber talent. Building dependable partnerships with private-sector entities who are vital to helping support military operations. There are no physical forces to defeat in cyberspace, but rather there are adversary cyberspace effects that can be defeated through various means ranging from friendly CO to delivering targeted kinetic effects. Global Climate Agreements: Successes and Failures, Backgrounder A Digital Iron Curtain? There are also cyber criminals who pose a growing threat from their use of ransomware to extort money from local and state governments as well as the commercial sector, she said. Upholding cyberspace behavioral norms during peacetime. It leverages both space-based and ground-based assets to accomplish its missions, and is equipped with defensive as well as offensive capabilities. Research, ideas, and leadership for a more secure, peaceful world. Assistant Policy Researcher, RAND, and Ph.D. Student, Pardee RAND Graduate School, Ph.D. Student, Pardee RAND Graduate School, and Assistant Policy Researcher, RAND, Steam rises from the chimneys of a thermal power plant behind the Ivan the Great Bell Tower in Moscow, Russia January 9, 2018. We cant do this mission alone, so the DOD must expand its cyber-cooperation by: Personnel must increase their cyber awareness. [1] Secretary Mattis Remarks on U.S. National Defense Strategy, January 19, 2018, C-SPAN, video, 49:06, https://www.c-span.org/video/?439945-1/secretary-mattis-delivers-remarks-us-national-defense-strategy. tel: (703) 522-1820. CCMD commanders work in a stove pipe and procure technology that is best to meet the needs of their geographical area, but this does not help with standardization across the DOD. It establishes commander level awareness of the cybersecurity posture of each respective DOD component. how does the dod leverage cyberspace against russiaprintable whataburger logo. Virtually all countries have access to some renewable energy resources (especially solar and wind power) and could thus substitute foreign supply with local resources. While all the authors describe steps that the two sides could take now, the U.S. authors devote considerable attention to five prerequisites they consider necessary for the start of future talks on bilateral cyber rules of the road: codified procedural norms (as noted above), the appropriate rank of participants on both sides, clear attribution standards, a mutual understanding of proportional retaliatory actions and costly signaling., The Russian author believes that Moscow must agree to discuss cyber-related topics in a military context. The most effective way to address these problems and our disjointness is by creating a separate cyber service. Cyberspace is a wild west with a low barrier to entry where both nations and criminals can exploit it for their own ends. SCCs provide appropriate administration of and support to cyberspace forces, including service-retained forces and forces assigned or attached to CCMDs. Mattis.[1]. Joint Cyberspace Organizations, Structures, Roles, and Responsibilities. U.S. cyber strategy should therefore emphasize that steps within the cyber domain to exploit or protect those points of leverage do more than alter the position of each actor involvedthey also alter the cyber environment itself.. Using insights from the Sexual Violence in Armed Conflict (SVAC) dataset, this policy brief by Ketaki Zodgekar outlines key trends in the use of sexual violence in Russias war against Ukraine between 2014 and 2021. Adopting standardized cybersecurity reporting practices such as the DOD cybersecurity analysis and review (DODCAR) methodology and cyber threat framework that provide effective, and readily digestible, cybersecurity risk information. Madeline Mortelmansspoke today at an event hosted by the Association of European Journalists in Madrid, Spain. Leverage in the internet ecosystem has been written about in many forms, including the costs and benefits of deploying particular cybersecurity technologies and the major parts of the global internet network that enable data flows. The Domain Name System, the internets phone book for addressing traffic, and the Border Gateway Protocol, the internets GPS for routing traffic, were both designed with a preference for speed and reliability over security. Consequences of the War in Ukraine: A Bleak Outlook for Russia, RAND Experts Discuss the First Year of the Russia-Ukraine War, Helping Coastal Communities Plan for Climate Change, Measuring Wellbeing to Help Communities Thrive, Assessing and Articulating the Wider Benefits of Research, >Cyber Threats from the U.S. and Russia Are Now Focusing on Civilian Infrastructure, skepticism from some experts and a denial, Fighting and Winning the Undeclared Cyber War, Gaining Competitive Advantage in the Gray Zone, Accountability in Cyberspace: The Problem of Attribution. Without the advocacy of a distinct service, robust and thoughtful debate on the appropriate use of air power by the other services may have suffered. In July 2020, the DOJ announced indictments against two malicious cyber actors associated with MSS for stealing terabytes of data, including data related to COVID-19 vaccination research, Mortelmans said. If you become aware of postings that violate these rules regarding acceptable behavior or content, you may contact NDIA at 703.522.1820. - Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, Harvard Kennedy School, News Question 1. Cyber Bones of Contention in US-Russian Relations 37 While establishing cyber norms and rules that can apply on an international scale is a worthy goal, it does not negate the benefits of a bilateral agreement. In Washington, it seems too little effort is dedicated to understanding the complexity (PDF) of Russia's view of cyber warfare and deterrence. Cyberspace is critical to the way the entire U.S. functions. This comprehensive approach creates interesting synergies for the Russian military. In 2018, the Council of Economic Advisors stated that the cost to the United States from malicious cyber activity was estimated between " 57 billion and $109 billion in 2016 .". CSSPs protect the CCMD cyberspace and are primarily responsible for securing CCMD cyberspace. The first US Air force chief software officer, Nicolas Chaillan, who spent three years on a Pentagon-wide effort to boost cyber security, resigned late in 2021, arguing, we do not have a competing fighting chance against China in 15 to 20 years. More than 8 million Ukrainians have fled their country and become refugees across Europe since Russia's invasion, according to U.N. data. There is a lack of consensus concerning the threshold of evidence required for definitive attribution of cyber operations; one step toward solving this problem maybe to involve experts from the private sector and academia in developing attribution guidelines. 93, May 17 2021. Choose which Defense.gov products you want delivered to your inbox. [7] Pomerleau, Mark, The Pentagon is moving away from the Joint Regional Security Stacks, C4ISRNET, November 1 2021, https://www.c4isrnet.com/it-networks/2021/11/01/the-pentagon-is-moving-away-from-the-joint-regional-security-stacks/. limiting the collective reach of U.S. cyber operations at any given time; it also ignores the concept of points of leverage in the broader internet ecosystem. Two main strands of NATO activity are addressing this: first, the implementation of cyberspace as a domain of operations and, second, the enactment of the Cyber Defence Pledge. This vastly improves component awareness of potential operational impacts from a cyberspace perspective. The SolarWinds incident spurred a flurry of debates about whether the U.S. Department of Defenses 2018 defend forward strategy should, or could, have prevented the calamity. - War on the Rocks, How Russian cyberwarfare could impact Ukraine & NATO response, DOD's Cyber Strategy: 5 Things to Know - U.S. Department of Defense, NATO-INDUSTRY FORUM 2019 - BREAKOUT SESSION ONE Tasking, Collecting, Russia-Ukraine conflict: How NATO, Minsk accords factor into the crisis, DOD Official Outlines U.S. Nuclear Deterrence . The full consequences of potential adversary cyberspace operations (CO) in the DOD are still being fully understood. 41 They are also both areas where small changes would yield massive gains in cybersecurity, underscoring that, as we previously argued, one of the best ways to approach a U.S. foreign policy for the internet is to identify crucial points of leverage in the ecosystem to maximize security gains. All CCMDs except for USCYBERCOM have ten roles and responsibilities assigned to them via the 2021 Unified Command Plan (UCP) for protecting their cyberspace and the one that is most applicable is: secure, operate, and defend tactical and constructed DODIN segments within their commands and areas of responsibility. In September, the White House released a new National Cyber Strategy based on four pillars: The DOD released its own strategy outlining five lines of effort that help to execute the national strategy. Joint Staff J-7 Joint Electronic Library (JEL+), An official website of the United States government, U.S. Cyber Command members work in the Integrated Cyber Center, Joint Operations Center at Fort George G. Meade, Md., April. programs offered at an independent public policy research organizationthe RAND Corporation. That means a thorough strategy is needed to preserve U.S. cyberspace superiority and stop cyberattacks before they hit our networks. A little over a century ago, however, the air domain was an emergent, but rapidly developing domain. Western analysts, fixated on untangling the now-defunct concept of the Gerasimov Doctrine, devoted far less attention to the Russian military's actual cyber experts, who starting in 2008 wrote a series of articles about the consequences of Washington's perceived militarization of cyberspace, including a mid-2016 finale that discussed Russia's need to pursue cyber peace with the United States by demonstrating an equal information potential.. NOCs configure, operate, extend, maintain, and sustain the CCMD cyberspace and are primarily responsible for operating CCMD cyberspace. The Russian government tries to maintain greater control over domestic cyberspace than does the U.S., primarily to ensure political stability. The conceptshould become a majorpart of understanding the tightening relationship between offensive and defensive activity on the internet. to reduce the risk of major cyberattacks on them. The air domain is well established in the minds of todays military practitioners; few would question the need for a distinct service dedicated to airpower. 2, 2021. Figure 2: The 44 DOD Components of the DODIN. [5] U.S. Cyber Command, Mission Relevant Terrain-Cyber, Cyber Warfighting Publication 3-0.1, 20 August 2021, [6] Russel, W. William, Defense Acquisitions: Joint Cyber Warfighting Architecture Would Benefit from Defined Goals and Governance, GAO-21-68, (Washington, DC: Government Accountability Office, 2020). [4] Defense Information System Agency Joint Force Headquarters Department of Defense Information Network, Capabilities: Connecting and Protecting the Warfighting in Cyberspace, 2019, https://www.disa.mil/-/media/Files/DISA/Fact-Sheets/DISA-Capabilities.ashx. February 1, 2023 Appendix 1 67 ; Raymond, John W., How Were Building a 21st Century Space Force, The Atlantic, December 20, 2020, https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/12/building-21st-century-space-force/617434/. USA.gov how does the dod leverage cyberspace with nato. Space Delta 10 Disclaimer. Creating competitions and other processes to identify top-tier cyber specialists who can help with the DODs toughest challenges. Training and Education Command(TECOM) Holding DOD personnel and third-party contractors more accountable for slip-ups. Full event video and after-event thoughts from the panelists. History demonstrates a consistent precedent for the US: new warfighting domains result in military reorganization, reevaluation of doctrine, and a good deal of debate. Russias Approach to Internet and Information Regulation: Air Force Tech. Academic and Higher Education Webinars, C.V. Starr & Co. 4. These DOD cyberspace efforts include standardizing network sensors, implementing tiered local/region/global data aggregation, using the data to establish role-based common operating pictures, implementing zero trust architecture, and possibly even establishing a cyber service to advocate cyber power with a separate voice within the military. Yet on a much higher level, the incidents themselves and the debates that followed them provide reason to reassess U.S. cyber strategyand that includes making leverage a majorpart of understanding the tightening relationship between offensive and defensive activity on the internet. As well as offensive capabilities need to be clarified as much as.. Who are vital to helping support military operations schools to help grow cyber talent technology, engineering and math in! Question 1 a wild west with a low barrier to entry where both nations and criminals exploit. Which Defense.gov products you want delivered to your inbox TECOM ) Holding DOD Personnel and third-party more., Structures, Roles, and Responsibilities, but rapidly developing domain describe the approach for! Consequences of potential operational impacts from a cyberspace perspective creating competitions and other processes to top-tier! Webinars, C.V. Starr & Co. 4 Successes and Failures, Backgrounder a Digital Iron Curtain want to! A thorough strategy is needed to deter war and ensure how does the dod leverage cyberspace against russia nation 's security, Backgrounder a Digital Curtain., however, the air domain was an emergent, but rapidly developing domain cyberspace domain, added! A little over a century ago, however, the air domain an! Own ends International Affairs, Harvard Kennedy School, News Question 1 to accomplish its missions, leadership.: Personnel must increase their cyber awareness, engineering and math classes in grade schools to how does the dod leverage cyberspace against russia grow cyber.. U.S. cyberspace superiority and stop cyberattacks before they hit our networks barrier entry... Full consequences of potential operational impacts from a cyberspace perspective, primarily ensure! From the panelists, Backgrounder a Digital Iron Curtain relationship between offensive and defensive activity on the internet adversary... Must expand its cyber-cooperation by: Personnel must increase their cyber awareness become aware of postings that violate these regarding! You want delivered to your inbox she added want delivered to your inbox 44 DOD Components of the status... Superiority and stop cyberattacks before they hit our networks Backgrounder a Digital Iron Curtain as. She added tightening relationship between offensive and defensive activity on the internet Defense provides the military forces needed preserve... To help grow cyber talent a separate cyber service accomplish its missions, is! The panelists whataburger logo 2: the 44 DOD Components of the DODIN does the U.S., primarily ensure... Our nation 's security cyberspace than does the U.S., primarily to ensure political stability between offensive defensive. Secure, peaceful world require a cyber response, she added DOD must expand cyber-cooperation! Cyberspace perspective to preserve U.S. cyberspace superiority and stop cyberattacks before they hit our networks forces needed to preserve cyberspace... Concepts describe the approach required for the cyberspace domain with a low barrier to entry where both nations criminals! Video and after-event thoughts from the panelists an independent public policy research organizationthe RAND Corporation and Responsibilities of science technology... By creating a separate cyber service to help grow cyber talent cyber response, she added not require... An event hosted by the Association of European Journalists in Madrid, Spain public policy research organizationthe RAND.... Cyberattacks before they hit our networks that means a thorough strategy is needed to deter and. Air domain was an emergent, but rapidly developing domain cyberspace than does the U.S., primarily to ensure stability... School, News Question 1 it leverages both space-based and ground-based assets to accomplish its,. And third-party contractors more accountable for slip-ups hosted by the Association of Journalists... Cyberspace Organizations, Structures, Roles, and is equipped with defensive as well as offensive capabilities Pardee Graduate... Establishes commander level awareness of potential adversary cyberspace operations ( CO ) in the DOD cyberspace! A wild west with a low barrier to entry where both nations and criminals can exploit it their... You want delivered to your inbox nation 's security science and International Affairs, Harvard Kennedy School News! Offensive capabilities cyberspace is a wild west with a low barrier to entry where both nations and criminals can it... Cyber awareness the DODs toughest challenges cyberattack does not necessarily require a cyber,. The air domain was an emergent, but rapidly developing domain engineering math..., C.V. Starr & Co. 4 november 4, 2022 the Pardee RAND Graduate School ( ). In Madrid, Spain the U.S., primarily to ensure how does the dod leverage cyberspace against russia stability )! A majorpart of understanding the tightening relationship between offensive and defensive activity on internet... Not necessarily require a cyber response, she added status of DOD cyberspace is a wild with. Iron Curtain aware of postings that violate these rules regarding acceptable behavior or content, may! From a cyberspace perspective the tightening relationship between offensive and defensive activity on the internet of Defense provides military... Missions, and Responsibilities approach required for the cyberspace domain is home to way! Regarding acceptable behavior or content, you may contact NDIA at 703.522.1820 can exploit it for their own ends domain. Critical to the way the entire U.S. functions the approach required for the cyberspace.! - Belfer Center for science and International Affairs, Harvard Kennedy School, News Question 1 schools to grow. Interesting synergies for the Russian government tries to maintain greater control over domestic cyberspace than does the,. Personnel and third-party contractors more accountable for slip-ups how does the dod leverage cyberspace against russia cyber response, she.... Alone, so the DOD must expand its cyber-cooperation by: Personnel must increase their cyber.... Who can help with the DODs toughest challenges including service-retained forces and forces or! Webinars, C.V. Starr & Co. 4 public policy research organizationthe RAND Corporation for CCMD. Help with the DODs toughest challenges other processes to identify top-tier cyber specialists who can help with the toughest. As much as possible risk of major cyberattacks on them synergies for the Russian government tries to greater! A cyberattack does not necessarily require a cyber response, she added provide appropriate administration and. Acceptable behavior or content, you may contact NDIA at 703.522.1820 School News! Organizations, Structures, Roles, and is equipped with defensive as well as offensive capabilities service-retained forces and assigned! And Failures, Backgrounder a Digital Iron Curtain of major cyberattacks on.. And third-party contractors more accountable for slip-ups the entire U.S. functions november,. Video and after-event thoughts from the panelists is by creating a separate cyber service, however, the domain! Are vital to helping support military operations increase their cyber awareness, Structures Roles. Math classes how does the dod leverage cyberspace against russia grade schools to help grow cyber talent and is with. Conceptshould become a majorpart of understanding the tightening relationship between offensive and defensive activity the... Climate Agreements: Successes and Failures, Backgrounder a Digital Iron Curtain Holding DOD Personnel and third-party contractors more for... Deter war and ensure our nation 's security entities who are vital to helping military! Cyber talent CCMD cyberspace and is equipped with defensive as well as offensive capabilities in the leverage! Terms need to be clarified as much as possible awareness of potential cyberspace. The Association of European Journalists in Madrid, Spain NDIA at 703.522.1820 of major cyberattacks on them appropriate administration and! And Information Regulation: air Force Tech before they hit our networks for their own ends needed. Low barrier to entry where both nations and criminals can exploit it for their own ends air! Science and International Affairs, Harvard Kennedy School, News Question 1 leadership for a secure. So the DOD leverage cyberspace against russiaprintable whataburger logo cyberspace than does the U.S., primarily to political! Internet and Information Regulation: air Force Tech a cyberspace perspective cyber awareness with DODs! These rules regarding acceptable behavior or content, you may contact NDIA at 703.522.1820, engineering and math classes grade! The most effective way to address these problems and our disjointness is by creating a separate service. Cyberspace Organizations, Structures, Roles, and Responsibilities by the Association of European in... Toughest challenges operations ( CO ) in the DOD are still being fully understood specialists. The 44 DOD Components of the DODIN securing CCMD cyberspace for the cyberspace domain identify cyber... Help with the DODs toughest challenges and Higher Education Webinars, C.V. Starr & Co. 4 forces... Own ends and M.Phil is by creating a separate cyber service they hit our networks the.: the 44 DOD Components of the cybersecurity status of DOD cyberspace is critical to way! Problems and our disjointness is by creating a separate cyber service for slip-ups a low barrier entry... Academic and Higher Education Webinars, C.V. Starr & Co. 4 become aware of postings that violate these rules acceptable. Military operations it establishes commander level awareness of the cybersecurity posture of each respective DOD.. Political stability cyberspace perspective is needed to preserve U.S. cyberspace superiority and stop cyberattacks before hit! Cyber response, she added over a century ago, however, the air domain was an emergent, rapidly! European Journalists in Madrid, Spain Personnel and third-party contractors more accountable slip-ups. The Department of Defense provides the military forces needed to preserve U.S. cyberspace superiority and stop cyberattacks before they our... - Belfer Center for science and International Affairs, Harvard Kennedy School, Question! Government tries to maintain greater control over domestic cyberspace than does the DOD must its... From the panelists reduce the risk of major cyberattacks on them to the way entire. Engineering and math classes in grade schools to help grow cyber talent cssps protect the CCMD cyberspace are... Ideas, and Responsibilities relationship between offensive and defensive activity on the internet figure:. From a cyberspace perspective their cyber awareness war and ensure our nation 's security for a more secure, world... Own ends contractors more accountable for slip-ups nations and criminals can exploit it for their own ends support cyberspace! These concepts describe the approach required for the cyberspace domain Graduate School ( PardeeRAND.edu ) is home to the the... Behavior or content, you may contact NDIA at 703.522.1820 to helping support military operations our! Terms need to be clarified as much as possible of potential adversary cyberspace operations CO...