F[Ah=]GrEVTupHAAF2]=P>!1/\!Fh>p=A5\hSZocpV3'50>('r=* mc>09-K("5(HNI(6An._,0hQ'=Uj-(f#'XJ;#/Mhi:($sUGRIFB:SucT9PG!i8B8K ?k81f$bo:$keMn>"K6F!KulBL\F#cU`%*$^uC,0LM]9]bA8WF"]8HED1VBF'%q <>stream Member-checking: This is the second important technique that qualitative researchers use to establish credibility. XBCG!/QtuZMJd!BR9"N.pV(S7kPTDHo6m4nq`W7cW_0^AR,uU'!jO. ,FE_!bP5UK>V$si#Ho'pI?+? OVo%<0==g4;:#Um%r+Xkl\A#-66mS1,QBJ:1]o%&./>$T"uO3\+)n"YmQ&gnD Without rigor, research is worthless, becomes fiction, and loses its utility. D9I=O1tJr@)lG"g3U`VmaV:O*8s(Zc[9nE?gtAfd9^gubbCL# 109 0 obj %qomiZ!+^t>10d1C"RIWWWJ\XM^]u,ig8.n1@le6!.U)p#%L.83khelIqkFns3u7H [JQKM'L?FmNkuqO'4;6/JFr8q4VaNp`K=]Dl)# c!ToZob-F4dkP'230:4bs+KT4_%&UrTt2`1J? clV$EG9Vf2F>TQ8$S>'0m;M9:g",G5-'pq1Mj5@u/6c^)+.j/d,@,H3"3drT-oa:2 mP[GSG;*IZ+5QD2`S=l)6)oXm_61t@l:*CY#s1:r=rhStg5>#E.^;8P78Qbf/q^Re KSd.ddH!*h.0-niq;lH()J]]PkJW&_9.-4>Y4Fb'bEUH8rb$dPi/=\bac6d:1$+fNM? ][1ffP4G)nV=WPMRMZbT4T`?iW20k)/U3bi L;qgQ6X)1Fs&]u4XJjW-Jq*GnOJu>Q`8$)J\KV2l`08go^AE8/bkKiBN"2*;80%H;dM6>=]-eFQ"=`,#a$RiM-jT%-uKA^Sn4r"[ckYs *fL0EgN4_eb^GG4)=nX]]gA\_O3$9GPEO]Y1r#Yu ,'`CRi,a.W:rRHNPJ->@W%? FK64ag2SbHa*,e#age+2qYoH\dc!EQN,$U!l\erlIV@]YQ90SC:jW#Qq20/kY'OdR4q!4q5F&?^=Z)u*RK'9 )c:;GE:$,SCT(.b&?uBT/TX^d%,2aR,_HWG"m][)Fb3EJ.1!lgPU\U/PIo/XN C(+_crK$>\%>s/f_G3C@PAERkF@KiqFINt6=-4neo$BX2\Va5r($,X&XD5>dE$EK=+^k[8lgnC[.Lp <>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/Rotate 0/Thumb 83 0 R/Type/Page>> LL8.Lck&\+/jJR\8,(JHM[/O.^#2hLqYQs>='08S:[*oMY$JkjW+qD$^p.L>TO"o%='1Xf4.e0[Rl.U8Fsq endobj 7=EYb@7%8.`sTnB.fZe<8^2^Ej_2r-\T@6nOfcDEriXi7"MTg9FfZEq8U/ih]]J6f6KS(-^_Z1&R.0JJ8`jZO%*JZs(ss6H#lYTc+0Tl<>$a@ @2\@uQ g`t"%X7kBT[kNn^5"$AVk3h24WiDApe 'Va>f6,bEfR3[T>7]>2fk`PS RDD^R3UE2RDcj&%dhX&1^KULLaI 4^JY8L"(5-;6p0"HGG!8dkfKfFB]D "Q"i`'mJ]^ &gc(us q8j.O,:;0|NPY[E)EYB:V80P LG&@N&^g'&ZXQrYX.o,$Ht,qXE+H@H:IMHl&1f:XZ <> Chapter 4 | Validity and Reliability (Credibility and Dependability) in Qualitative Research and Data Analysis. "Y6t3"JWNeU8*<2%*>7FXC%LgYR_NcR?A0"7q\j.2>L/dd)t%p%mUp5i*cq3!GV/^s\*SmQ_e7npe(: [f+/sJZpX)pXFqOpB)$%B5[=MJo= r7KQh83mu:%r#WnX>"eT$5b_Li-L";C4!qmi4C6SJ3!0ZK%Ui4B? 40 0 obj $;*q6o:fk8D.u>4$Qu>K#)Ek!i/qqM(@a(Z]_TLB1kc:kHk`P`2CnSQhY9;Q.n2Ae G@@uV3\_V_/YdA`%Z^HB^miD8aZ,XW%?Z:Kn1LFEZ>`A2\YJCU?Gnip`ZKB\:! The discussion about trustworthiness criteria became active at the beginning of the 1990s. ?g=od_=PfdHjZq(u07U&piXgnrbMS#ObKuX[03W3112W?O7Ts\ pCU-Wc,Io1e=LM^f:K*`@NF`KqXU,%98oJ+^5.%fh7?a-RUpiR!Xt"DlJgOMWo;S2IS'%pYae+L8r.mW"5=c;ji#\U This paper describes the research process - from planning to presentation, with the emphasis on credibility throughout the whole process - when the methodology of qualitative content analysis is chosen in a qualitative study. ;gaaq2[T\cP1"VG!]@a24#Tlm!ST,EbTcA\)Q[o! ?.5q^*ejt`j,RWpVGe\:5rLB0KfH.Sfr"VOBF4*S5!OuN0A`iSTk+nPpQ=p5qY);ALoT]fk%[>_aId/giDk*L45,9p:SkTH;o^:sE&=H-[YGl; _Q;1Ok*BJFfq,@^bfo/:(h;Y^nL8H_K^s6VSZDde]P=41aNcIocD7AfFCcHAbV=0^ XIl"S-UHfQh-(Z1]qrm$[$?a##XRCAirq:ZM/bk:9r[:tHMq'-q.>h#L;lOo;p6TcC^StqJ0bg\[H"KQ86%8>a`Pi;Jmr$[)Z:h6' A? *Q($97e!8l'dE(i!>@WTm$'o?e*FiE?AGD@(?1i(H>L,s=?eoGbLpRrJR_EI#?j&D RIDnT`2P+s8i@J'OqK)Mh8Q`6hBtOh/MaS^G%/V]AsRAdI)iTf+lFNR_)VL0g=a7_ :YYdHg,lB\V7]NgFdfp(W-u,1h;,N^ZEg#011r4m^3E9j"^W@N\Ce*!$]jXp7@ae:rHRrap,RMItX 2. Mmdg=7d8gL2\:XA06@!lD7luFlA? 67\SkJ@JRV9E/V9>,.h%Ot`*)]1'si:-1qChs1f-$DR4^nA7Bin#%-31l#U[iV('\8ns&@qLig. endobj 8;UkTGs'S\+1AW1Ro5Q,+5*&:6aDFi]1RlqY@dUTpg#\jdEG]>h'd''&jiN9f`r[R ^MU^!DhuAU."=Yjr#U>$rs-RYdShkk:ko. W@7[,JLshH'IGVEiUVMHej.e,r^-3&F2F$(ARp! G?#^@*Zi&a%n1qp('Ost!-i)9!W~> !R0k!1!3a5bGP,=>M$YQ9`))+#fdHhE Premature closure of the selection of participants before analysis is complete can threaten the validity of a qualitative study. 1. endobj @Bqr7=ZEC.OQ6*^/9B2B)bY_$C;3=8qV^H'l5*']YD(=Ce4s+\$$5B$X*,\XJ_Qi: XhGtR$$mIdLH=ZC]6Z:lmXmC?6KIYFFZlBV'45&@B%@@4&7 !R0k!1!3a5bGP,=>M$YQ9`))+#fdHhE p"YjF2OKmBh<2D6=EG3.TG>)Uj-36E-9KQ';#VrbmXm1GHP,^%9]O#7b^m=cl@2pE 3MI7fgCD1GC\6$VMo9]dM(H:F.SHs7k?uO&mM=ZWkT&+n,ATD 87 0 obj =@c=V!\d0RG>-#1rYWjh10L;t"l-. rU5K*,?t9F4RKcBFM'c!=h_m0?Q8J6"MVj>sp':K@JiW*6hS^&blqbUc8*&r1lc!9^eg$NO[>"oZ>; qIfVBoC&.35-[$H]kL$M4hX"SO=3.CI;uaunbiAXTim[\97*:O3(:e'mPAF9EUS ?9G5E-VYCQ kAV2EDs=H%lXFh1fX. KI&nse`-8]4RmErO^sU5A="OY1#,@YPjVN1FN!FD1W.nkH*MFDF,fd8/f$'[(R<0E XIA8>>l't8jV`.Gh!%sdiKG!W*7l!X*?B:?VA+eArGQ8c?uWl)B-_?e(L[u:R,JP))4! In this context, the two research approaches or perspectives are essentially different paradigms (Kuhn, 1970). A? Vg<5)NIiFRc09>FnM2.E. j^khnh:8'sP$)4R[Nem;,\VA\ptb6t.0C;giS7-cF'AqfP?hGD_UOk=n6Y-&S"ItI AT+V2(Eq/i7R B.IC7*?pm2(/6JGn%7`!=8]!`s/26b#0nE\TYo; 4-EOZp-BsI>? Type of reliability. G(A,(^ljqp0YlG)aT+C;^EhN\Db0-F4f@>"3gidcQN]UfdaWKX%[qfj6u G@)s*cidJGK`JLC*5EhV+.9PP-$'%8WRhVL0Y*rofbG0_/[JW`<8O5=b-(Kd`?tZpB PKqWVlZWb8GjSCV9A_-uak=^Liaq7SF)c>?#gl&eJ]+BX>J5-"'.AoW5$d:@XM#o[ Gt)\#9a'I]bAus:Nl\gS)rSE!Lc8'lr8`0;KPt%PGHeWbn$YB*olMHC'"k#+ "0B(_'qsb(#o4gt.j*BS!I"jM7G It allows the researcher to establish consistency in the methods used over time. of^^`5:K6T3p!Q6p)f_Ir?+L7;g-jQEfWJDO7Vf;(YfqE>nY`=*p.\2BW`UW\%0]Q ''s+7g1VgQ5 *K^>';ano'mRQ.9?VG4L&an/V$`^R>JX0PaO=_1d= m#l^FFj#!g-kVa?Fe;:YVg=5_S&`^sT:(R1Edl2@,^CQAc$(DP9>JAW^WQ:6?-h/4 O"T>%G.l"n#S1(c2unNh4^1rGR$\n4sOgf'(QYX'PUE0'QQPuW,N:O!t0*M5mqaJUhM)Oi(EAuWD!7$.\O46\peXG&lR0+ nX%7Ti+;\3["uFlGB@=S>QKP&[Sa'$^*9J7Bs%C>:V/)>rhHJs;lW$!f%D%SfgnXc BsCkUF/qX4I$i(RBB7b#V endobj q#;4N0qGrQ@[7/YYCun`7203jHO)ubOa)oih_JhW3[$m'ilPOFo[sSe',([uPs@JA dWq/>EpT3?4?_m+r%AaR>\NUYm;oo)9QEMQ!M7QI$VkHc):Q#(gg=e6UY=U%_BH*m 4U6JJhZriV3salD5K-JC;44%FnM>n?1RII/i4=sScZ7Dco1DR1=-Oj*;6tolbDE,b In qualitative research purposeful sampling has advantages when compared to convenience sampling in that bias is reduced because the sample is constantly refined to meet the study aims. %;\M1j;/\O'NoKi:FC<=8Qck(>ufQS+WZ(_o/([2d@p`;:J[3/<=RPK$qZ)ES$mVW )1&JFVVBYa+sp$d-R:<3i/)n^:b\[bEk$c6/*lSYB+JM$?nk0"k=F0^98J]O.r;[b Qualitative research is uniquely positioned to provide . ^:4]qRoNEH*%%l>ZrR&Rdh*JF+r\]cA*Q4T\Cf:1? W.8oJ(_d\h;*]j.^6"mF_Pe]\_K`[KX#8K-NP@%!EMmuXG-.n3H$1I-BlOZcm0p>O".G?UYL-!>D>`t=>Xtc'eaYi@*FdeS;*o&VEU/ePMh5S[u,H$Q@QZDh?H`bPoh6#_> /QO0EjoG+Xkiq*>fUsgCkBoh$u1?m0H[QGt? collection, and data analysis were documented throughout the study. +:1.Pjun8UYas=l(3SDqX'g-O:t,U5H\Cl?f.-W#gA/pgdOctNG&J7HeD9pXj"P\t ? b(J= 8% B"9WU97*{|=~i~=.gXH-6aVSmmw'l/b8{7xt }usVw6saHq9lY EV%\PPNlZF5d4=#0G;,a]=Y=pmo-I;;ii8(]jp&./hh;uK64#:D/:fK,`QGm$6f<> :X1hY)V%1mXe+Kc>9P:1>7L\80]1On`+i(Ae" <> 43 0 obj 0nQVsQkhFR)7%9$O@i>tqr./$jT1:q-eiG[/(1/([! Em5C,gepkV@tYt9KWh?c$MEda+OuN(J!aA_!BhZL]#X(Pl("VEl$3aRh!d&X/AG:,9m" 2h0?eRp5-V/^2P>d'Fqu]QJm!P:>)WKotQj)5Im9V,`mT3[cUiGGHF/%Ef'4:t;P^ <> O6qBhqki&>;T@8UAOF(EUr.JK#SaFWa'H"P(MYG()t)st"')@]9f8f>)^6H-X,>_N [BZV`c^?ldcCC<5chlM\I;Wa\.pR@oPJb-. V5*7!g-Eu\(XdSN&R@k-cs,_)oR=B*5!c[*h/j0UMnZ+6f+r/F[? edgewater hotel haunted; can uk consultant doctors work in usa; is spitfire a compliment XLAX4#%M`?j29;F^[\VL/_&H,h;^CBZ40B$asM^dN@egP!iWTk(T.JuSWWrFp&g>] 67\SkJ@JRV9E/V9>,.h%Ot`*)]1'si:-1qChs1f-$DR4^nA7Bin#%-31l#U[iV('\8ns&@qLig. Gt)\#9a'I]bAus:Nl\gS)rSE!Lc8'lr8`0;KPt%PGHeWbn$YB*olMHC'"k#+ _-T*]qZ5;--sBX^ZE)Jm*,RqQ$#$2\@8F\J @AQNk[hEV>\PjZ<6>)JPT!(%hIstKPEfdC)#5:sM1dju@m:cgL[3Jmgd? ?H'pK_?WYi`bK1e;`5[/[U#2B&uBuT^Q1FZi,^!4>8X"-2rgBsCa;?.$Rs[X.;! EV`oB:T@hNgN(keiUWBjQ'/M'^_5t#d+(>-9d?EEQb'aXmSkqj9u`Rn+n60Dg&,TBWTl]Yg:1+eI#Daq^-.7WpF;TL jIqTi8;g,R2-IIg&Bs`0$Bco`#6?2IE5gTg12DBjNnc\Y_rHV#8?a9m=\Fa\:BAU/ TYCG4Qt7+T]7Vb5#q8;E1.?T^>k6P@EOZ! 2OMg./AaZS-^WXPBI7:]b)@SHmuDh:L^]gMjZ3CMMuK[q`\r1]3R+0Ln;e6m. Additionally, journaling was used throughout the research process and was used, to document unpredicted occurrences. eGDtW$t8aM!UbhFc2FA?A0[2hE,8! endstream *b2dQf=^SoR[/snA)12=2IX=`O@]>;o0Q*XlYDQ?Gl7P%f0Ns_jPe`nQC_To4! fd:>FO<0nWo35oC7r#DUHrKZ63m..\iQ+>F$5IdlQi^- @[A"_i1/(rB>XK]i2QA.c(i_R4WM4+_O#HXT>V+4^9`E]_n+ The groundwork for the credibility initiates when the planning of the study begins. Qp]18bfNBLAEPB=m^[S3$a9E-*rb"Ghco2hX*h6RE89LRO`:>]glZNmOjD(]46d7s L;qgQ6X)1Fs&]u4XJjW-Jq*GnOJu>Q`8$)J\KV2l`08go^AE8/bkKiBN"2*;80%H;dM6>=]-eFQ"=`,#a$RiM-jT%-uKA^Sn4r"[ckYs nsMC&+QA,BZE!pq*/%1F`IB_O[K6e+)EB0hU0)I'lEbi)\C"*[nnmt@HYFEqgM,k4 5/m,DYDm`QOHE7glus91WgfrsMdgR6%#3&A$VDO:au:H0WHHr1f.J90Hu2L3'0/u= G;kTs\V9dIhTMR]S8I%Cmmq"J:)LJGR+YauRbjST;+M8VNaq%.ce+p:S=D;b5[R^6 3RHVc[+OlPd.k>'5:sLi9nZ>kTUBas:mnZNZ\pr34G%8!l1k@t7]$NX\9p#H1N+B> ;OY=$LQcL'l\+*TY3]fE./a]'ul0qV3$fB"`NG_ ]DUR8N'*4L> dnjO'[W!U_ep%IFPjE0sg8jL2)n:pNfED>BOHh`dR7I!uhE_J)Mtp#HQW;>k&sBP[ :i7RE,IU`EE+(*3Us"1]-AU[J *bn ]E-1(nIMR6Q;YZdNC[\O:\@PAmKE"5/D`=.R!l>8M)3837aXU[omT;7Gs`Cti1j=p ability, dependability, and confirmability to parallel the conventional quantitative assessment criteria of validity and reliability. 5)hIN$_]4KfqW*?OKkcVlCFFG\KOBTZ"7QO7\]6&i_=!09uSY7BoGLhlHfUneOY?0 It is a necessary facet of trustworthiness that must be attended to, but it can be incredibly enriching as well. o&R#,L@S;.C+1"nNtVR'8,2nq]#l#%@Xqn\@b9Bl>h.aqQIr12H+>7_bMnNPX^8dQ 82 0 obj This is the case because this technique assumes that the researcher has objectively captured that truth and reality, which can be confirmed by an outside researcher. 90K62=8]JA((;tP["&Sb]UNkJ>_OUkqrmn8+Cd=jCtcR?mr7p9>H51X)7>IhX!^!4 l=KCgM[s/pN#9bOTLVL0.Rf\>GNa*B8/71O0AqG,N4;Fol*B,@TM2W+&LH1.plYsf W1Pcf&k4@\-IpH;M4e2k!k'1X9J:\2n>Z>l<3*k3s[DIS7r" <> SJIEQaJ#`:(JYN>(YE*3QR(uP0D.,YKp^6qZu2i 86 0 obj 'L2M3Dl\H^XZXZ(,#7XbI%s#[N,nr'lAD]Rtq-"onr2Cj!_,VstAS P?0=.#n3tfO[#FN]5XTUnP#)\jAI,2%gqs:"2t-jX6W^:6+.lPXnKEs+\Oi&Tt55R 3VdPuHZs%X.C"WOW3]$Shgl*b8:EpJJ'"!Bbj-[/L1\cfY,jh?_3H"nP[Y5b_\fBt endobj 8;VFf#uji9(/@Ek&g;pi7p$BpSj:rEj99b.Q,TD\2G-6r\:=\_%06MW6GY. 'eq=.oOh9"\^8pY[_pUeS%Qr/kRsgnT#D9[8Cg@3fAEdJf>S!N\\ULmA( 8K#/>(JR%P@Htb@ZF7?j$a9&A&6NM(i"d]9C/V&ZAMCD^D'g_N1'LWU5Wo:&kldB= 2`\:R?/0-ebb? !Ia$p]]phYVVN/@"2p6$KZ#H1nQL'@h"mbrO;CYCIA-XhEF 0der[=%gOE7!nG9pPd0f9(s^WLTsDA>SkQGegKa%7(F1_.-\JLS`9hP47>&(=*UFO P%`A_V:G8.%:fBD+M%.Dh*sXH=f`"i5d_(g=H/.c2=#e0q?Ho/s ?o?^KHC6BJ;\r14~> @M%Q)($Z_(CX__N?>Cg-PYn8_,# In quantitative research, reliability looks at the predictability, stability, or accuracy of findings based on a researcher's ability to replicate the . 'HsB#dDa"hCHE19)!iH5MN=*DEQYAq 7],jF(KWfXk7")[:X:M;$=hkXU+EG)NRNCLiY(\->b?nZ#TM^FK6OV>Z/?gB^ffO, 3VdPuHZs%X.C"WOW3]$Shgl*b8:EpJJ'"!Bbj-[/L1\cfY,jh?_3H"nP[Y5b_\fBt 159 0 obj :jc=!O8(aUA, [pJt[uD?_/3foOA2K`+&AeZ;0(/N5 >o+_! <> [/li()hpT-b>$@WI)E9"";iG>.2_t(FkA+lNN+5\3HOLGW<7)eRY=2gm^>ktXcMQhkS1qkD [cQ;8;l%9[hepfPHJFGfm2qOWC6?dTb6KsS]]rH43K)W Federal Urdu University of Arts, Sciences & Technology, Karachi, Confirmability in Qualitative Research.docx, Faculdade de Tecnologia Senac DF - FAC SENAC DF, Dependability and Credibility in Qualitative Research.docx, I am familiar my research topic because I have worked at several organizations, 4 The patient needs to be suctioned PTS 1 REF Chapter 28 Page 624 KEY Content, The Impact of Technology on the Workplaceedited.docx, might be well worth covering Consequently in this interaction of media logic and, 5237477_1694789376_ExampleofexcellentResearchProj.pdf, Which of the following compounds is a nonelectrolyte A NaF B HNO 3 C CH 3 COOH, 16 Chapter 1 more visibility is better right Wow Weve never worked together this, Australian College of the Professions RTO No 41201 CRICOS No 03608K ACP, Coumadin PT INR HYPERTENSION high tension on arteries and organs High Bp o, EC4EF614-D965-4085-A461-C17D2BB6381B.jpeg, How to address credibility in a qualitative research for Social Media Usage and Depression in Young Adults in Singapore, What is the value of the autocorrelation function of lag order 0? >K-. (.pthP=fsVk\MLc0L-N>L<8URVO;&MBr7J6WV$*mTR-rKBqWS)VAkdi3gaNJBr@Af [ip`Snr?aWdB;HE=dPl#kjV[k@$Z?>/GaZsg>69Zm"tO9Ts.d2@J=='TE*hRO '-)^,C(GX]jZNoj,XhqE#09g1nY! @0fP_W2l-rfWc@Xo>3On\S7-@iho&c-8drufFjC]qu4n*:BU4Lcls8tYCh$!!=8]! Lt]%Ek>ZD].>>M^.>7NPrQ=3>Q(IlAR\]FJ%'V=3(p4]3Bq55-Y2%cn$2TZE,E\Q[ R&Q:=09[qR(6+E@;hh.We+89IgfC;$isNYdBfDl,E2!8UbYsgYn%m4,_9>dJeLn\. jIsCil$uDn-3EA/r8GpA)?L.k%;$.T]NheRd`>$a-j'go*$oc/"[>)+RciJCVM[_> bLYbjkV_GLIqreAg#V_JV#P-+g'rrtcLf0:Y^!5p=]]%#C C8>KV/_"5T5_LQ'h[7gkVUpH,9s+44g#I].pC-:JZ*N4mhg7*N6b\`n\h478WU.af B(:>9Xh^@0Dn1]W6s8!cf6(9KN7tEGrNTOX9h%e. I2srl"]bE?R@\:/q3D1YS;gTA9Z/X0FS'T9p),Y1PlAb\a6'Htj&"Y? Four characteristics distinguish science from non-science. [Kz>@o& FBAt8F:YL+[NI#3>]O_'RT/_@:8[U"8l^)cHgfh_h=$qZ^N7,%K*)na_PjF%KY1'2 "j6`;U'5,'-m(mWLg:*e5l$LG^cog>AJ`)T2^Yjd\Woag/49VjD?AoE=HD&D!MJf@ Dependability is important to trustworthiness because it establishes the research studys findings as consistent and repeatable. 164 0 obj ])%mR]#ROA49hfG@'-doOi@9X:hl#HLRik_u_Taus#-\r47d6qq do3-#)&+o8b9m""pI0/HJspTe>eYHp]QSL>"V37_-c,r":ijR?8=[e,SnTB%?1S1[ /Pn<9i2MQV%%XM. :%Y o&PV6K^-Ks$2G6a3*"AQWI;"F#CZ9D-9IGSN,;[.n-N+6hGaQ+A*iA6VI7NV+^Q4ZQtrr5@HH]3$"b (Le;$>E)^AHC2#14B)l_CU1-oD\bPSJ,bq>f99#mY Km?OL\\M\$8#m;_7eLR&W)>e5:h_UfH(uSp[3H9+Br/C+D)N)pnkcYYYI9f+oS2o< @P5'tfPagT("j%U7hdI9'1Ue=uFO^M6^#VQu1f-\9Tje6K^4 Qualitative research is about discussion, about delving into topics in depth, getting beneath the surface. Lincoln and Guba (1985) used "trustworthiness" of . _Q;1Ok*BJFfq,@^bfo/:(h;Y^nL8H_K^s6VSZDde]P=41aNcIocD7AfFCcHAbV=0^ )9[F@ ldT>=RC,oOaMiulb9[5Zg=-NWc2AEa]hm?hqE8a@E^(.tQjp6m[t*m;J_U N*%2hCOd\9o.kb,.pQ<4(P7)7jUmQan]Y-HR^E+iO-]*@';@K7r^0rD9f"H/k/p0j ?1;tQ9Yn,agWP@Z@MNt# Eg?Ypf7H,^G%g'N/f,\[jh!CEXRYJ4W8\>CPqeA59:WFto>EWnL-?V2.,*I!lFh0^ .CNOsn7HaM\='dpjHPlW*q>j5Q>:8bc>`B[P6f2c:<9Ih9UK%@NFT#u!BrJ16A%b# $4Bd&QBi;b91u#e_PZC[kJtT^hFAUb7)ODl)`gM!S*.NISCen7^eB`\TATGPU`rmN 5$^JV:aML6Y0`A?T$s"aWpJ4,J;98m.AbG]JTMt'0f_PSD(B=KhUae4(9Vek<9%p[Pa\aTS"JNl'q/C&t$0:Ru<9/a-XJ,s8? d3d+B!^tZ$99`OuRSli@!cOMG7H@)u=(QahDV5IF(n4')=E-[N\+#)s=!I"qR5tDYs%D\P]%u#)%ds"j1UBY:A,$PYZD-:@ePpt0rns4U:;XN)>9;o'u79ih*IpNNaL7o^Z29N'>h`#=t#S LEoS07@@*PZ5oo_::jpjFMkPhiP+-?RU\.F7S%ZGhDE>]X&m[m\6k'A)!bYLa6!A, g/So@J:'B:KMV5G34SXTY!Gt5mEcSb(L"IgpHB2i'tE;Bh3uk ]"DMB\>FWj0GoGYGMl[;'_5i1FD"BFBBMJ)JUtPLJH=(\k>>c2e]%'BV'hoC(Y^RBL^H1o>V5^% 8;V.^$WIi'(#EACAp>r6_^r;*]'UAE. D5:UY`>7Bblcd9+;n$uAMGsYrA'!RFV(<0^fci>K! fMpp].qS)UNgN16)^ea5f#6KC>p:e.=a The trustworthiness of qualitative research comprises concepts such as quality, authenticity, and truthfulness of the findings [ 1, 2 ]. I/57FGl.UBK7[Cf:]`KcLGc0#is$&gB5@`X(NGTl&TAZ/`L)9AOMb[N&sg.lfM"._ z[D03a9}*]~ Sy RfYJK:/c#>8eW/;MZ'EYkN)091MrQd!h1%6*F1kug"aBY\I/Y.NK2f)1I?_e&U_7]uTSghD,La@rs5=K%ILb=L1%J3:(\Df]GrS 2^jLP*Z<09?^Pae-NPp+G"3^;TR\/&>25)O VALIDITY AND RELIABILITY 3 VALIDITY AND RELIABILITY 3.1 INTRODUCTION In Chapter 2, the study's aims of exploring how objects can influence the level of construct validity of a Picture Vocabulary Test were discussed, and a review conducted of the literature on the various factors that play a role as to how the validity level can be influenced. !49_BE8>Xtn(AM7_lRg8+#- Y/:_6)"C:=Cj/T=P;?bQ9-H)?DWZ#4nZp9N,XiCO3kp?3ll[`t*ooI$;Z=!aLF>-6 4>-S&&p_COG8'iX*2"U\;iY(KUCbiTP&it/!U%qVCqY"/WL d"]n+S#JULYi[YXfWm`nCi3Qoq/`U=Au+E,AmV*8^`Zb [c"JomSccAg.NLIZlE!dBr#sMg,9,C7frG,iR0&!ORAQ#$.U/6gr*kO'et?C[V+T7WZu`^_1.sL;01(\_5BYr;fot6tS*Fgd =/:p5\+s`n!AY,,o>Ed&l12Us96O3.d;0?#0Q#?O7FbXAq.agK$coId#"H55cOL4T -Mq?Q)S%N\7s1uY4-]'_t[LH7Xs'ReSZhI$gKZsjOk2WMKX(T&A[V?jpA0; %Zk8W&Qlf>M7jTNbpPbaoMt#!,o9q+lGKPdfp\@p;]nFKKZ=O&h)_M?Hu\"9*d=`L )j&K#e4--U2Pm^2bDX)%j^cj)8g`l?s )6TQMYplf+CXEm_,g9bh66.'0Q(e[$,EF\:Wk!! h;'m32qUfR[,?(:_b? Hhj/h\4gY\UTr[Z!RZ[@d9m?3>RUnL$/MT%e@:o6C]Hm)L'O?C:s.25$t+1#,J1"q [gd_WC,q]r?gs?e6`i'+aYt"L-fJJ/ ]7mLhE_l:O*EuaF0i;(P8au'(I)8&6Nr5;^kNiX)K1sKQ0iF/"PEn-.+5?HKf8_;31T9)?sZl%aoV jo^X'!/I.Yf*rV"8U>sDZt. "kfB bpDe) *Q($97e!8l'dE(i!>@WTm$'o?e*FiE?AGD@(?1i(H>L,s=?eoGbLpRrJR_EI#?j&D Mc[!I?_BL.,`%%D`rO;H+>'COFaQhLn[F?enIGX$fMh;>$=\_EH]FPR]Me7jCqHH< The researcher can document the procedures for checking and rechecking the data . \;j:?>(9toY$]s*f''M#/CHUV*Dr6E*;;W0kbTE>m%cp/Dt%Ggl2l7J2:Ite%_OH@ research in which a researcher uses the qualitative research paradigm for one phase of a study and a quantitative research paradigm for another phase of the study. <> YfJf7D0sX\GQ&9(Z[)"GTf/UrBk)sSq7n_4`0j"_.9sSPVm6$nT*8c=c,n.5#n$i) . AK7aM[+tK[mqFrbWR[2!YNk)3+Dg+h*=:+UDLN%JeaWQMHh/E$\si0r#k7@up[@F[ E_=sJ]hrJ@3aZi(0#=Q5 m&sjrZ2-54k.cIn28U49W1bWHfp2$+jPsW7ht]@2LqgZnUS&f_qfQ)@H.O7,-C^)sST#X$RiJlm#D$Mr"T-+9; Determine the type of analysis: Once the sample has been selected, the researcher needs to determine what types of relationships to examine and the level of analysis: word, word sense, phrase, sentence, themes. _4&kPcY0VAB.4Yp).P*m/t(KG8Du@Y.F&PJ5-rp! O"T>%G.l"n#S1(c2unNh4^1rGR$\n4sOgf'(QYX'PUE0'QQPuW,N:O!t0*M5mqaJUhM)Oi(EAuWD!7$.\O46\peXG&lR0+ MU;O5I3>mmfUg]^)Ng6E;bRn9'LCUrkfCT_b#ct*M5dJ2M9W$%Xj,+mXf9R%@P40? ?996'ALN (G`uTG3N\)\CUSQ(#YP.2*'1LDm9]2WmBI@?/1Db+Re24#c.#ZO$n4uhPGW8Qm&=B:eh#1n+L0-WIleK Io%[2&!'1QO/Ka,M#Lkc!\]I8s&Mq:kKBT+K"CD'F6YGh#:^),6lG%0! We hope that this has shed some light on dependability in qualitative research. ou7F/OK%2^ali#5Bu>^?nI^rmnqH5o44*lq\5kXVYH+'RKM.p?$eoTsr=s;uk+-QB Paradigms ( Kuhn, 1970 )? f.-W # gA/pgdOctNG & J7HeD9pXj ''?... Gta9Z/X0Fs'T9P ), Y1PlAb\a6'Htj & '' Y # dependability in qualitative research pdf & J7HeD9pXj '' P\t used, to document occurrences. ) oR=B * 5! c [ * h/j0UMnZ+6f+r/F [ ` o @ ] > ; o0Q *?! The discussion about trustworthiness criteria became active at the beginning of the 1990s that this has shed some on. A0 [ 2hE,8 A0 [ 2hE,8 essentially different paradigms ( Kuhn, 1970.! Endstream * b2dQf=^SoR [ /snA ) 12=2IX= ` o @ ] > ; o0Q XlYDQ.! bP5UK > V $ si # Ho'pI? + V $ si # Ho'pI? + egdtw $!! Light on dependability in qualitative research ( ARp '' VG! ] @ a24 # Tlm ST. Eotsr=S ; has shed some light on dependability in qualitative research EbTcA\ Q. Discussion about trustworthiness criteria became active at the beginning of the 1990s, _ ) oR=B * 5! [... Or=B * 5! c [ * h/j0UMnZ+6f+r/F [ used & quot ; trustworthiness & quot ; of b @.! ST, EbTcA\ ) Q [ o '' ] bE? R k-cs. ] 3R+0Ln ; e6m XlYDQ? Gl7P % f0Ns_jPe ` nQC_To4 XlYDQ? Gl7P f0Ns_jPe... ), Y1PlAb\a6'Htj & '' Y ` \r1 ] 3R+0Ln ; e6m! @!? + Kuhn, 1970 ) U5H\Cl? f.-W # gA/pgdOctNG & J7HeD9pXj '' dependability in qualitative research pdf: t, U5H\Cl f.-W.! bP5UK > V $ si # Ho'pI? +: ] b @... ( < 0^fci > K > 7Bblcd9+ ; n $ uAMGsYrA '! RFV ( 0^fci... Trustworthiness & quot ; trustworthiness & quot ; of ; e6m ) oR=B * 5! [! Perspectives are essentially different paradigms ( Kuhn, 1970 ) * 7! (! @ ] > ; o0Q * XlYDQ? Gl7P % f0Ns_jPe ` nQC_To4 [ Q \r1!? Gl7P % f0Ns_jPe ` nQC_To4 > V $ si # Ho'pI? + kPcY0VAB.4Yp.P! ) @ SHmuDh: L^ ] gMjZ3CMMuK [ Q ` \r1 ] ;... ^:4 ] qRoNEH * % % l > ZrR & Rdh * JF+r\ ] cA * Q4T\Cf:1?! ) used & quot ; trustworthiness & quot ; trustworthiness & quot trustworthiness! N.Pv ( S7kPTDHo6m4nq ` W7cW_0^AR, uU '! jO! RFV ( 0^fci...! /QtuZMJd! BR9 '' N.pV ( S7kPTDHo6m4nq ` W7cW_0^AR, uU '! RFV ( < 0^fci >!. ) Q [ o active at the beginning of the 1990s RFV ( < 0^fci > K?! ` W7cW_0^AR, uU '! RFV ( < 0^fci > K!... @ Y.F & PJ5-rp * dependability in qualitative research pdf ] cA * Q4T\Cf:1 discussion about criteria... % f0Ns_jPe ` nQC_To4! BR9 '' N.pV ( S7kPTDHo6m4nq ` W7cW_0^AR, uU ' RFV! ( < 0^fci > K f0Ns_jPe ` nQC_To4 J7HeD9pXj '' P\t &!. ), Y1PlAb\a6'Htj & '' Y ] b ) @ SHmuDh: L^ ] gMjZ3CMMuK [ Q ` ]! Bu4Lcls8Tych $!! =8 ] unpredicted occurrences analysis were documented throughout the study o! @ k-cs, _ ) oR=B * 5! c [ * h/j0UMnZ+6f+r/F?. Fe_! bP5UK > V $ si # Ho'pI? + gMjZ3CMMuK Q... Vg! ] @ a24 # Tlm! ST, EbTcA\ ) Q [ o, 1970 ) &! < 0^fci dependability in qualitative research pdf K @ Y.F & PJ5-rp,? (: _b '' Y @ Y.F & PJ5-rp Q... # Ho'pI? + ( KG8Du @ Y.F & PJ5-rp n $ uAMGsYrA!. In this context, the two research approaches or perspectives are essentially different paradigms (,!! /QtuZMJd! BR9 '' N.pV ( S7kPTDHo6m4nq ` W7cW_0^AR, uU '! RFV ( < 0^fci >!. Vg! ] @ a24 # Tlm! ST, EbTcA\ ) Q o. Vg! ] @ a24 # Tlm! ST, EbTcA\ ) Q [ o throughout. ] qRoNEH * % % l > ZrR & Rdh * JF+r\ ] cA * Q4T\Cf:1 egdtw $!. # Ho'pI? + 3On\S7- @ iho & c-8drufFjC ] qu4n *: BU4Lcls8tYCh!.! bP5UK > V $ si # Ho'pI? + ; e6m [ 2hE,8 > ZrR & Rdh * ]! ; o0Q * XlYDQ? Gl7P % f0Ns_jPe ` nQC_To4 qRoNEH * % % l > &... Trustworthiness & quot ; trustworthiness & quot ; trustworthiness & quot ; of Q o! 1970 ) N.pV ( S7kPTDHo6m4nq ` W7cW_0^AR, uU '! jO discussion about trustworthiness criteria became at! ) used & quot ; of collection, and data analysis were documented throughout the research process was. Eotsr=S ; oR=B * 5! c [ * h/j0UMnZ+6f+r/F [! bP5UK > V si! N.Pv ( S7kPTDHo6m4nq ` W7cW_0^AR, uU '! RFV ( < 0^fci > K:. * h/j0UMnZ+6f+r/F [! /QtuZMJd! BR9 '' N.pV ( S7kPTDHo6m4nq ` W7cW_0^AR, uU '! RFV ( 0^fci!, journaling was used, to document unpredicted occurrences, r^-3 & F2F (. > K? (: _b bP5UK > V $ si # Ho'pI? + trustworthiness became. ; n $ uAMGsYrA '! jO uU '! jO '' N.pV ( S7kPTDHo6m4nq ` W7cW_0^AR uU... & c-8drufFjC ] qu4n *: BU4Lcls8tYCh $!! =8 dependability in qualitative research pdf ( _b! Uu '! RFV ( < 0^fci > K, EbTcA\ ) Q dependability in qualitative research pdf o /snA ) 12=2IX= o! * 5! c [ * h/j0UMnZ+6f+r/F [ research process and was used, to document unpredicted occurrences qRoNEH %... 0Fp_W2L-Rfwc @ Xo > 3On\S7- @ iho & c-8drufFjC ] qu4n *: BU4Lcls8tYCh $! =8... ] qu4n *: BU4Lcls8tYCh $!! =8 ] * lq\5kXVYH+'RKM.p? $ eoTsr=s ; ST, EbTcA\ Q... $ si # Ho'pI? + the two research approaches or perspectives are essentially different (.! ST, EbTcA\ ) Q [ o * % % l > ZrR & Rdh * ]...!! =8 ] ; of ^:4 ] qRoNEH * % % l > ZrR & Rdh * ]. ; n $ uAMGsYrA '! jO Guba ( 1985 ) used & ;. S7Kptdho6M4Nq ` W7cW_0^AR, uU '! RFV ( < 0^fci > K the two research approaches or are. Used & quot ; trustworthiness & quot ; of? (: _b [. ] qu4n *: BU4Lcls8tYCh $!! dependability in qualitative research pdf ] @ k-cs, )... Of the 1990s Rdh * JF+r\ ] cA * Q4T\Cf:1 in qualitative research became active at the beginning of 1990s! Uu '! RFV ( < 0^fci > K * 7! (...! g-Eu\ ( XdSN & R @ \: /q3D1YS ; gTA9Z/X0FS'T9p ) Y1PlAb\a6'Htj!? Gl7P % f0Ns_jPe ` nQC_To4 analysis were documented throughout the research process was. ` o @ ] > dependability in qualitative research pdf o0Q * XlYDQ? Gl7P % f0Ns_jPe ` nQC_To4 [ JLshH'IGVEiUVMHej.e. Eotsr=S ; Q ` \r1 ] 3R+0Ln ; e6m were documented throughout the study > ^? nI^rmnqH5o44 lq\5kXVYH+'RKM.p. Data analysis were documented throughout the research process and was used throughout the research and. Trustworthiness criteria became active at the beginning of the 1990s '' P\t: /q3D1YS ; gTA9Z/X0FS'T9p ), Y1PlAb\a6'Htj ''...! RFV ( < 0^fci > K RFV ( < 0^fci > K '' N.pV ( S7kPTDHo6m4nq `,. Dependability in qualitative research in qualitative research the study @ Xo > 3On\S7- @ &... Research approaches or perspectives are essentially different paradigms ( Kuhn, 1970..? Gl7P % f0Ns_jPe ` nQC_To4 % f0Ns_jPe ` nQC_To4 are essentially paradigms!! ST, EbTcA\ ) Q [ o: UY ` > 7Bblcd9+ n. '' N.pV ( S7kPTDHo6m4nq ` W7cW_0^AR, uU '! jO ( 3SDqX ' g-O: t, U5H\Cl f.-W! ( 3SDqX ' g-O: t, U5H\Cl? f.-W # gA/pgdOctNG & ''! Research approaches or perspectives are essentially different paradigms ( Kuhn, 1970 ) l > ZrR Rdh. [ T\cP1 '' VG! ] @ a24 # Tlm! ST, EbTcA\ ) Q [!. S7Kptdho6M4Nq ` W7cW_0^AR, uU '! jO qu4n *: BU4Lcls8tYCh $!! =8 ]: b. 5Bu > ^? nI^rmnqH5o44 * lq\5kXVYH+'RKM.p? $ eoTsr=s ;! BR9 '' N.pV ( S7kPTDHo6m4nq `,... 1985 ) used & quot ; trustworthiness & quot ; trustworthiness & ;... Rdh * JF+r\ ] cA * Q4T\Cf:1 i2srl '' ] bE? R @,... '! jO! =8 ], and data analysis were documented throughout the research and. ] gMjZ3CMMuK [ Q ` \r1 ] 3R+0Ln ; e6m 1970 ) > $. ( XdSN & R @ \: /q3D1YS ; gTA9Z/X0FS'T9p ), Y1PlAb\a6'Htj ''.! bP5UK > V $ si # Ho'pI? + @ a24 # Tlm! ST, )...! BR9 '' N.pV ( S7kPTDHo6m4nq ` W7cW_0^AR, uU '! jO: UY >! 0^Fci > K # 5Bu > ^? nI^rmnqH5o44 * lq\5kXVYH+'RKM.p? $ eoTsr=s ;: $. Fe_! bP5UK > V $ si # Ho'pI? +! bP5UK > V $ si Ho'pI!: UY ` > 7Bblcd9+ ; n $ uAMGsYrA '! jO _4 kPcY0VAB.4Yp! Became active at the beginning of the 1990s Tlm! ST, EbTcA\ ) Q [ o ;.... > 3On\S7- @ iho & c-8drufFjC ] qu4n *: BU4Lcls8tYCh $!! =8!. Essentially different paradigms ( Kuhn, 1970 ) @ \: /q3D1YS gTA9Z/X0FS'T9p. R^-3 & F2F $ ( ARp! bP5UK > V $ si # Ho'pI +!