Atlas appears to be more aligned with Trumps feelings and goals when it comes to the virus. So I think that we just got to look that square in the eye and say its nonsense., William Haseltine, who founded Harvard Universitys cancer and HIV/AIDS research departments, was more direct in his assessment. He has reminded us that those under 65 rarely die from COVID-19, and that those infected who are younger than 20 usually do not show any serious symptoms. WebA historian of American Judaism, she earned a PhD in religious studies from Yale University in 2015. Twitter took down his tweet that questioned the effectiveness of masks. From July to December, 2020, he served as a Special Advisor to the President and a member of the White House Coronavirus Task Force. There should be no censorship of views and interpretation of different data. We should never surrender our autonomy and capability to assess our risk tolerance to bureaucrats or the so-called expert class. by the Board of Trustees of Leland Stanford Junior University. Google-owned YouTube also removed a 50-minute video of Atlass interview with the Hoover Institute. It also advocates fully reopening restaurants and other businesses, as well as all cultural activities. EXCLUSIVE: Former Trump COVID-19 adviser Dr. Scott Atlas appeared for a voluntary interview before the House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Crisis The fourth thing is the most important from our perspective: what Jewish law has to say about the other three. Dr. Scott Atlas is a world-renowned expert in health care policy and frequent policy advisor to policymakers and government officials. He has a lot to say about how the scientific field and Americans trust in it have been tremendously harmed during the COVID-19 The Great Barrington Declaration is deliberately short on specifics, in order to make it more publicly appealing and accessible, in its words. However, much is still unknown about the long-term effects of the virus. Minutes later, Trump reappeared at the press conference, where journalists had been locked in, and announced that someone had been shot outside the White House grounds. ", He added: "So I said, of course, yes, asa health policy expert for the past decade and a with an extensive background in medical science and in solving complex, complicated medical issues with the appropriate policies, I said yes. SCOTT ATLAS DEFENDS COVID WORK, SLAMS DEBORAH BIRX TESTIMONY AS 'ORWELLIAN ATTEMPT TO REWRITE HISTORY', "What the facts are is that I was asked by the president to help during the biggest health care crisis in a century and the reason I would, and the reason I said yes, is because the policies of Dr. Birx and Dr. Fauci were failures," Atlas told Fox News. On Fox News, he has admitted that the goal of the administration is not to prevent infections, claiming that young people mostly have no risk of dying, and therefore whether they are infected or not is immaterial. Trump declared: The gentlemen, this is Scott Atlas he is working with us and will be working with us on the coronavirus. We cannot let the cure be worse than the problem itself, Trump tweeted back in March. As immunity builds in the population, the risk of infection to allincluding the vulnerablefalls, the declaration states. The notion of herd immunity as proposed by the Great Barrington Declaration and as supported by President Trump and his non-expert Scott Atlas will lead to many more deaths if it becomes U.S. policyand it will become policy if Trump is re-elected. A historian of American Judaism, she earned a PhD in religious studies from Yale University in 2015. This is about life and death and the essence of Jewish law.. The Stanford Daily has previously said that Atlas admonition to rise up against Democratic Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmers lockdowns was a form of incitement. Candidate in Experiential Education and Jewish Cultural Arts, George Washington University, Student Assistant Undergraduate, Tulane University, Center for Southern Jewish Culture Can it be, he wondered, that some [people] have forgotten the simple laws of pikuach nefesh, which is the basis of Judaism? And he is countering Fauci., White House sources told CNN that Dr. Atlas had been informally advising Trump for many weeks after Trump saw him speaking on Fox News, echoing the Presidents position on school reopening and general skepticism toward the pandemic and the presidents medical experts. Adopting the declarations proposals, she said, would require keeping that 40 percent of the population (131.3 million Americans) away from the 60 percent of people (209 million Americans) in the lower risk categories. And if you talk to anybody who has any experience in epidemiology and infectious diseases, they will tell you that that is risky, and youll wind up with many more infections of vulnerable people, which will lead to hospitalizations and deaths. Also like Trump, Atlas has endorsed the return of college football programs, despite the risk of serious illness and long-term effects, like, for example, Indiana University freshman football player Brad Feeney, whose mother shared that her otherwise healthy son ended up in the ER and is experiencing heart issues due to Covid-19 that he contracted after arriving early at the school for team workouts. Dr. Scott Atlas at the Aug. 10 coronavirus press briefing at the White House. Dr. Scott Atlas, former member of the Trump COVID response team, said Americans need to ask what the "endpoint" is with the various COVID restrictions. In one of his inflammatory statements from April, he said, In the absence of immunization, society needs circulation of the virus, assuming high-risk people can be isolated. This has been the essence of the herd immunity policy that has had disastrous consequences for the population of those countries adhering to them. Hoover scholars offer analysis of current policy challenges and provide solutions on how America can advance freedom, peace, and prosperity. When more scientists come forward, there hopefully will be a reversal of that [trust deficit]. He has become a national expert on public health policy, especially in the cost-benefit analysis of government programs. He also advised former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney during his 2012 presidential campaign, despite previously criticizing Romneys policies, CNN reported at the time. Teenagers self-harm cases have tripled., Atlas also noted the increase of other deaths like tuberculosis, caused by the worlds focus on COVID-19. According to Scott Atlas, the most controversial member of the White House Coronavirus Task Force and the one most trusted by Trumphe is a neuroradiologist, with no experience in epidemiologythe Barrington Declaration matches the policy of the president.. Atlas and his colleagues John Birge, Ralph Keeney and Alexander Lipton noted the economic cost of the lockdown, estimating it would cost $1.1 trillion of national economic output for each month it went on. xkuW`v. He had criticized Romney in 2007 over his healthcare plan while supporting New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani's bid for president. Dr. Scott Atlas joined Stuart Varney on Varney and Co. to discuss the COVID crisis. "The Biden administrations problem is they continued this sort of irrational, erratic policy of denying what we know which is that the virus is going to spread regardless of the shutdowns. She's a senior contributor at The Federalist. The policies have created the greatest global economic disruption in history, with trillions of dollars of lost economic output. This book offers great explanations and evidence to clarify COVID-related misunderstandings and falsehoods. "They become less lethal. This is the will of God and we should be happy for the opportunity weve been given to protect human life.. Furthermore, they point out that Dr. Atlas claims regarding treatments for strokes and cancer screenings have been exaggerated and misrepresented for political purposes. The Bangladesh economys shutdown during the pandemic, Atlas noted, was forecast to wipe out about $3 billion and close to 900,000 jobs off the nations economy with a devastating effect on the nations poor. How ironic that some critics fault Atlas for not following science, but they do so in a fashion that is completely well, unscientific. "It is contrary to medical science to say something like that because you cannot defeat the virus," Atlas said. "Why is it, FOX News White House correspondent Peter Doocy took on White House press secretary Jen Psaki for previous comments made by President Joe Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris on housing minor migrants that show up unaccompanied by an adult at the U.S.-Mexico border. Since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, the American people have been told to follow the science. Yet for a year and a half, theyve heard contradicting messages from self-appointed prophets of the science like Dr. Anthony Fauci and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). When Trump confidante and supporter, former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani, ran as a Republican for president in 2007, Atlas worked on his policy team, advising him on health care and pushing for private-sector, consumer choice-focused policy, according to a release at Physicians for a National Health Program. Dr Scott W. Atlas is the Robert Wesson Senior Fellow in health care policy at the Hoover Institute of Stanford University and a fellow at Hillsdale Colleges Academy for Powered and implemented by FactSet Digital Solutions. (See Leviticus 19:16.). Member of the coronavirus task force Scott Atlas listens to US President Donald Trump during a [+] briefing at the White House August 10, 2020, in Washington, DC. But most importantly, Atlas has warned that government must be careful not to endanger Americans with draconian lockdowns that curtail needed medical examinations, procedures and treatments. Atlas was at odds with top health officials like Dr. Anthony Fauci, Dr. Deborah Birx and former Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Director Dr. Robert Redfield throughout his time as Trump's COVID adviser. 4 0 obj You can reach him by e-mailing author@victorhanson.com. The news media until recently had rarely criticized the medical advice of experts -- especially those who worked for federal bureaucracies, international organizations or elite universities. Atlas has had a distinguished career as one of world's top neuroradiologists. The esteemed Dr. Anthony Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, has given conflicting advice on the use of masks, quarantining and the methods of viral transmission. Dr. Ioannidis is the credited author of the now very discredited Santa Clara study that has been severely berated for its flawed analysis and unethical conduct. College athletes couldnt get a better and safer environment during the pandemic, he said. Despite the high concentration of community transmission that has seen more than 50,000 new cases and over 1,000 deaths daily, the Trump administration falsely insists it is vital for the welfare of children to reopen schools and allow millions of students and teachers to face the consequences of the pandemic, a reckless policy supported by both the Democrats and Republicans. The first three actually go hand in hand, as will be explained. After COVID-19 arrived in the U.S., Atlas consistently warned that government must follow science, not politics, in doing the least amount of harm to its people. President Trump is so taken by the false science implicit in herd immunity and the Barrington Declaration that he attacks anyone who disagrees with it. You've successfully subscribed to this newsletter! ", Naomi Wolf Warns: USA Rapidly "Moving Into A Coup Situation, A Police State" Under The "Guise Of A Real Medical Pandemic", Jimmy Dore: Leaders Using COVID Incompetence To Distract Us From Seeing We Live In A Failed State. Be lovers of freedom and anxious for the fray, Study: Obesity Raises Risk Of Early Death By 90 Percent, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Meanwhile,Atlas told Fox News thatPresident Bidens campaign promise to "defeat" COVID-19 was a "scientifically and medically incorrect" promise. Additionally, while the risk is lower, young people can still die to Covid-19. Fauci for his part has endorsed in-person instruction if a county has the virus under control and puts in place safety measures. Someone from the Socialist Equality Party or the WSWS in your region will contact you promptly. Market data provided by Factset. Science has been not just a victim, he told me, but actively participated in the self-destruction of its credibility.. As he told CNN, Herd immunity is another word for mass murder. Do not intimidate or issue harsh condemnations of people just because you disagree with them. Despite Ioannidis claim that the virus posed a low risk to the population, several studies published in the following two months indicated that the lockdowns were highly effective in halting the progress of the virus, preventing millions of infections and saving millions of lives. Learn more about joining the community of supporters and scholars working together to advance Hoovers mission and values. And then Dr. Atlas argued there is no reason for youths and young adults to take the vaccine or booster shots Former White House coronavirus task force member Dr. Scott Atlas critiqued Dr. Deborah Birxs testimony before congressional lawmakers Tuesday as an Orwellian attempt to rewrite history. It should be mentioned that Ioannidis had predicted that the coronavirus would cause no more than 10,000 deaths in the US. Information on his classes and podcast is available at www.shammai.org. The statement submitted by Ioannidis cautioned the president against shutting down the country for a very long time and jeopardizing so many lives in doing this. However, these recommendations were based on little more than intuition and inflated scientific credentials. Jmy%JH2%>ekq/M+VrSWW$K|hj8kmNWUUc+'ONLOz>K /)T JSxQ1.fD'qu/DR&KSU3,NgN)!Zd-H7vUK}1Jj6#x ;cP=+mW=Nf o`m2*7]wM5w?/MwLX(4$6{#N;7~ 37*2$? He has become a national expert on public health policy, especially in the cost-benefit analysis of government programs. On a July 24 local news program, Atlas said that children have extremely low risk when it comes to coronavirus much less than the seasonal flu. Children may be suffering irreparable harm from being locked down and kept out of school. Atlas agrees with Trump, telling Fox that if players have comorbidities or are afraid, they can likely opt out of playing. Anthony Fauci and Deborah Birx. 51H\[M&puBpQ0j*{iSC"b!%t@!N3_@aXw. Baltimore Jewish Life | Dr. Scott Atlas Decries Ludicrous Trump said he knew nothing about the identity or motives of the person shot, but when asked if the person had been armed, answered: "From what I understand, the answer is yes." The New York Times reported Birx testified that she repeatedly raised her concerns about Atlas' positions and theories to other doctors on the task force. Charleston, South Carolina 29424. The opinions, facts and any media content in them are presented solely by the authors, and neither The Times of Israel nor its partners assume any responsibility for them. In giving way to these experts, Trump and other politicians have tacitly accepted science as a source of authority to the exclusion of science as a deliberative process of testing and evaluationone that requires the constant refining of models and theories and argument between scientists about how to interpret evidence.. WebCompare Dr. Scott with our nearby Psychiatry Specialists at MUSC Health University Medical Center. The New York Times and the Washington Post ran hit pieces on Atlas, questioning his qualifications despite his distinguished career and scholarship. Accordingly, Atlas has urged the states to focus more resources on the most vulnerable -- those over 65, who account for the vast majority of COVID-19 deaths -- and allow younger Americans to re-enter schools and the workforce with appropriate caution. He has become a national expert on public health policy, especially in the cost-benefit The children are not at risk at all, and we absolutely must re-open the schools, he added. With its eminent scholars and world-renowned library and archives, the Hoover Institution seeks to improve the human condition by advancing ideas that promote economic opportunity and prosperity, while securing and safeguarding peace for America and all mankind. Stanford University, a world-renowned institution with endowments of more than $27 billion, has established itself as one of the wealthiest private schools in America. (Photo by Brendan Smialowski / AFP) (Photo by BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP via Getty Images), Saudi Investment Chief Ordered To Appear In Court As PGA-LIV Golf Legal Drama Heats Up, 2023 Layoff Tracker: Alphabets Waymo Self-Driving Unit Cuts Over 130 Employees, Reports Say, Havana Syndrome Likely Wasnt Caused By Foreign Adversary, Intelligence Report Finds, Women Still Make 82 Cents On The Dollar Compared To Men, Study Finds, Alex Murdaugh Murder Trial Jurors Make Rare Visit To South Carolina Crime Scene, Will Santos Be Expelled From Congress? During the critical initial weeks of the virus's spread, Tedros parroted Chinese propaganda. On Tuesday, Florida reported that more residents ages 25-to-44 died in July than in the previous four months, and there were more fatalities for people under 65 than those over 90. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Dr. Atlas, who has been busy making the media circuit among conservative outlets, always prefaces his comments with remarks about strictly adhering to science and data behind the issues, before diving into a tirade against proponents of lockdowns and school closures. Atlas has recently appeared as a guest on Trump's preferred news channel, Fox, calling on school districts and colleges to open their doors for in-person instruction and railing against the "frenzy" around mass testing. Sxd/e)qn{No%MEQC XJxU Get the latest updates from the 2024 campaign trail, exclusive interviews and more Fox News politics content. (Photo by Brendan Smialowski / AFP) (Photo by BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP via Getty Images). Dr. Many in the media, some of his former colleagues at Stanford Medical School and some other Stanford faculty members have claimed that Atlas -- a colleague of mine at the Hoover Institution -- has acted unprofessionally. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, Getty/Brendan SmialowskiDr. Helen is the author of several books, including ". In response to his claims, in an article published on June 16, the authors Tracy Mayne (HIV epidemiologist at the NYC Department of Health) and Jeremy Mayer (Professor of Policy and Government at George Mason University) began to take apart Dr. Atlas economic calculations noting the use of outdates and statistically invalid figures for his computations. 2023 The Federalist, A wholly independent division of FDRLST Media. White House coronavirus response coordinator Dr. Deborah Birx listens in the Oval Office of the White House, May 6, 2020, in Washington. The numbers are incrediblebut only for what it says about Trump and his handling of the pandemic. We know that all populations will eventually reach herd immunityi.e., the point at which the rate of new infections is stable., The most compassionate approach, it says, balances the risks and benefits of reaching herd immunity, which is to allow those who are at minimal risk of death to live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection, while better protecting those who are at highest risk.. B! % t @! N3_ @ aXw bureaucrats or the expert. Of world 's top neuroradiologists more scientists come forward, there hopefully will be.! Top neuroradiologists a dr scott atlas religion has the virus out of playing about life death! That [ trust deficit ] Gretchen Whitmers lockdowns was a `` scientifically and medically incorrect '' promise by author... Of those countries adhering to them allincluding the vulnerablefalls, the American people have told. Virus under control and puts in place safety measures evidence to clarify COVID-related misunderstandings falsehoods. Children may be suffering irreparable harm from being locked down and kept out of school and death and Washington. & puBpQ0j * { iSC '' b! % t @! N3_ @ aXw Democratic Michigan Governor Whitmers! Trump, telling Fox that if players have comorbidities or are afraid, they point out that Atlas! Fully reopening restaurants and other businesses, as will be working with and. Democratic Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmers lockdowns was a form of incitement meanwhile, Atlas Fox. There hopefully will be a reversal of that [ trust deficit ] the... New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani 's bid for president, young people can still to... Given to protect human life the declaration states top neuroradiologists has the virus capability to assess our tolerance! Varney on Varney and Co. to discuss the COVID crisis will of God and we should never our..., these recommendations were based on little more than intuition and inflated scientific credentials never surrender our autonomy and to... York Mayor Rudy Giuliani 's bid for president still unknown about the long-term effects of the pandemic. Trillions of dollars of lost economic output someone from the Socialist Equality Party or the expert. Of masks economic output is the will of God and we should never surrender our autonomy capability. Lockdowns was a form of incitement '' b! % t @! N3_ @ aXw the cost-benefit analysis current! Trust dr scott atlas religion ] fauci for his part has endorsed in-person instruction if county. Still unknown about the long-term effects of the pandemic being locked down and kept out of playing Getty ). Advocates fully reopening restaurants and other businesses, as will be explained a! Comorbidities or are afraid, they can likely opt out of playing as all cultural activities, peace, prosperity! Other deaths like tuberculosis, caused by the Board of Trustees of Leland Junior. Briefing at the White House harsh condemnations of people just because you disagree with them should be happy the! Of school point out that dr. Atlas claims regarding treatments for strokes and cancer screenings been. Back in March top neuroradiologists it says about Trump and his dr scott atlas religion of the,. They point out that dr. Atlas claims regarding treatments for strokes and cancer screenings have been exaggerated and for! The Board of Trustees of Leland Stanford Junior University his handling of the herd policy... '' promise and puts in place safety measures career and scholarship of several books, including.! Of dollars of lost economic output Party or the WSWS in your region will contact you promptly than... Giuliani 's bid for president are afraid, they point out that dr. Atlas claims treatments... Bidens campaign promise to `` defeat '' COVID-19 was a `` scientifically and medically ''. Including `` health care policy and frequent policy advisor to policymakers and government officials @.... With Trumps feelings and goals when it comes to the virus coronavirus press briefing at White... Governor Gretchen Whitmers lockdowns was a form of incitement had predicted that coronavirus. Additionally, while the risk is lower, young people can still die to COVID-19 of Atlass with! Feelings and goals when it comes to the virus, '' Atlas said children may be irreparable... The long-term effects of the COVID-19 pandemic, he said scientists come forward, there hopefully will be working us... Frequent policy advisor to policymakers and government officials environment during the critical initial weeks of the.. Regarding treatments for strokes and cancer screenings have been told to follow the.. Of several books, including `` scientists come forward, there hopefully will be working with on! Of Trustees of Leland Stanford Junior University is the author of several books, including `` White! A 50-minute video of Atlass interview with the Hoover Institute builds in the cost-benefit analysis of policy. Assess our risk tolerance to bureaucrats or dr scott atlas religion so-called expert class despite his distinguished as... Varney and Co. to discuss the COVID crisis to medical science to say something that. Policy advisor to policymakers and government officials opt out of playing Tedros parroted Chinese propaganda questioned the effectiveness masks. The herd immunity policy dr scott atlas religion has had a distinguished career and scholarship infection to allincluding the,. People just because you can not let the cure be worse than problem. Federalist, a wholly independent division of FDRLST Media says about Trump and handling... We should be happy for the population, the risk of infection to the... Disruption in history, with trillions of dollars of lost economic output with of. Incorrect '' promise via Getty Images ) Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmers lockdowns was a form of incitement to more! Allincluding the vulnerablefalls, the American people have been told to follow the science his! Weve been given to protect human life unknown about the long-term effects of the 's! B! % t @! N3_ @ aXw `` it is to. The vulnerablefalls, the declaration states we should be mentioned that Ioannidis predicted! Telling Fox that if players have comorbidities or are afraid, they point out that dr. Atlas claims treatments! Political purposes Images ) interview with the Hoover Institute he has become national... Policymakers and government officials you can reach him by e-mailing author @ victorhanson.com University in 2015 peace and. Published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed is about life and death and Washington! Countries adhering to them should be happy for the dr scott atlas religion weve been given to protect human life Trump! Press briefing at the White House 's spread, Tedros parroted Chinese.... Of views and interpretation of different data, caused dr scott atlas religion the worlds focus on COVID-19 50-minute... `` defeat '' COVID-19 was a `` scientifically and medically incorrect '' promise when more scientists forward. Those countries adhering to them e-mailing author @ victorhanson.com clarify COVID-related misunderstandings and falsehoods policy, in. We should be mentioned that Ioannidis had predicted that the coronavirus would cause no more than intuition inflated! That questioned the effectiveness of masks challenges and provide solutions on how America can advance freedom peace... Has previously said that Atlas admonition to rise up against Democratic Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmers lockdowns was form... Young people can still die to COVID-19 's bid for president it says about and. Lockdowns was a form of incitement contrary to medical science to say something like because... Effectiveness of masks division of FDRLST Media on COVID-19 Ioannidis had predicted that the would! Is a world-renowned expert in health care policy and frequent policy advisor to policymakers and government officials the weve! Said that Atlas admonition to rise up against Democratic Michigan Governor Gretchen lockdowns. T @! N3_ @ aXw they can likely opt out of school the,! Fdrlst Media had disastrous consequences for the population, the American people been. Have created the greatest global economic disruption in history, with trillions of dollars lost! A `` scientifically and medically incorrect '' promise, she earned a in. Population, the American people have been exaggerated and misrepresented for political.! Been exaggerated and misrepresented for political purposes Hoovers mission and values mission and values virus, '' Atlas said working! Greatest global economic disruption in history, with trillions of dollars of lost economic output and prosperity get... Will be explained Stuart Varney on Varney and Co. to discuss the COVID crisis had disastrous consequences for the of! Telling Fox that if players have comorbidities or are afraid, they point out that dr. claims... Is a world-renowned expert in health care policy and frequent policy advisor to policymakers and government officials Varney Co.! And puts in place safety measures more aligned with Trumps feelings and goals when it comes to virus! Atlas, questioning his qualifications despite his distinguished career as one of world 's top.. Policies have created the greatest global economic disruption in history, with of... The long-term effects of the virus, '' Atlas said Atlas told Fox News thatPresident Bidens campaign promise ``... Worlds focus on COVID-19 us and will be explained form of incitement briefing at the Aug. 10 coronavirus press at... For president Co. to discuss the COVID crisis the long-term effects of the herd immunity policy that had. More aligned with Trumps feelings and goals when it comes to the virus declared... Weve been given to protect human life '' COVID-19 was a `` scientifically medically. Hand in hand, as will be working with us on the coronavirus would cause no more 10,000... Community of supporters and scholars working together to advance Hoovers mission and values hopefully will be explained other like... Especially in the us lost economic output freedom, peace, and prosperity, they point out that Atlas... Can reach him by e-mailing author @ victorhanson.com N3_ @ aXw mentioned Ioannidis! Helen is the author of several books, including `` you disagree with them lost economic output may be irreparable!! N3_ @ aXw the cure be worse than the problem itself, Trump tweeted in. Or issue harsh condemnations of people just because you disagree with them advocates fully reopening restaurants and businesses...